Facebook has halted a sketchy practice of asking some new users for their outside email credentials in order to verify their accounts. After a Twitter user on Sunday shared a screenshot of Facebook asking them for the password to their email, the social media giant faced intense criticism from security professionals. A spokesman for Facebook told The Daily Beast that it would no longer engage in this practice.
Facebook has maintained that the password prompt only appeared for a small number of users, specifically new users who were signing up for Facebook on desktops with email addresses that did not support OAuth. OAuth, which is an open standard security protocol used by Google, Amazon, Twitter and Facebook, lets users grant third-party clients access to their information without giving them their password.
Engadget tested the company’s claim on Tuesday morning that it no longer asks for email passwords, and it checks out. We signed up for a new Facebook account with an iCloud email address, which doesn’t use OAuth. Facebook then sent a five digit security code to that iCloud email; it also sent a separate email with a “Get Started” link, both of which could be used to get into the new Facebook account — but crucially, it never asked us for the email account password.
Facebook is facing more scrutiny over how it handles user passwords after numerous privacy transgressions over the past year. While the social media giant is always quick to fix whatever initial problem occurs, the fact is that new problems always crop up. If a 3,000 word manifesto released last month by CEO Mark Zuckerberg on a new “privacy-focused” vision for the company is to be believed, the company wants to take privacy seriously from the top-down. But the recent evidence isn’t too encouraging.